All case studies

The Beard Struggle · Grooming · DTC

How The Beard Struggle boosts remarketing with Consequential

Remarketing outside the Americas failed silently because international phone numbers were formatted incorrectly. Klaviyo could not process them, so the SMS never sent.

2x
Improved returning user traffic
+4.5%
Recovery of lost revenue
$19K/mo
In potential sales recovered

Their unseen challenge

Broken international remarketing

Issue
  • Remarketing outside the Americas failed due to improper phone number formatting for international customers.
Effect
  • Klaviyo could not process non-standardised phone numbers, so SMS campaigns failed for every customer outside the Americas.
Result
  • Reduced re-engagement with international customers who never received promotional SMS.
Impact
$19K per month in lost sales

The solution

Consequential signal and flow monitoring

Consequential monitors the data moving between Shopify, the CDP, and Klaviyo, so a formatting fault in one field is surfaced as a revenue problem rather than a silent one.

Cross-tool signal checks

Every field that feeds a downstream flow is validated, not just the ones on a dashboard.

Root cause in under a day

The exact broken field and affected geographies were identified within 24 hours.

Continuous coverage

Once fixed, the same check runs forever, so the flow cannot break again unnoticed.

The results

What changed with Consequential

2x returning traffic

International customers started receiving campaigns again and came back.

+4.5% revenue recovered

Sales previously lost to a silent formatting fault came back into the P&L.

Weeks to hours

A problem that went undetected for weeks was diagnosed in a single day.

No engineering lift

The fix was scoped precisely, so the team shipped it without an investigation project.

Root cause found in under 24 hours: improper phone number formatting for international customers was breaking every Klaviyo remarketing flow outside the Americas.Detected in 1 day, previously undetected for weeks

Find your first leak in 48 hours.

No credit card. 30-minute setup. White-glove onboarding included.

$15B in brand revenue under management · all inbound